Skip to main content

Etsy vs Payhip vs NiftyFifty for quilt patterns: 2026 fees

Fees checked

Here is what happens to a $12 PDF quilt pattern on each site, using each one's published US fees. NiftyFifty and Payhip's free plan come out the same, and both leave you more than Etsy does.

Fees and take-home pay on a $12 pattern
Where it sellsWhat's chargedFeesYou keep
Etsy$0.20 listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee, 3% + $0.25 payment processing$1.59$10.41
Etsy, sale from an Offsite AdThe same fees, plus a 15% Offsite Ads fee$3.39$8.61
Payhip (free plan)5% transaction fee, plus Stripe's card fee of 2.9% + $0.30$1.25$10.75
NiftyFifty5% fee, plus Stripe's card fee of 2.9% + $0.30 at cost$1.25$10.75

So what's the difference?

We won't pretend the fees are the whole story: on a $12 pattern we tie with Payhip's free plan. Here's what is different.

  • Buyers are already here. A Payhip store is your own storefront, so every buyer has to come from you. NiftyFifty is where quilters already come for blocks, swaps and free tools.
  • Only quilting. Your pattern sits next to other quilt patterns, pantographs and classes, not next to everything else for sale on the internet.
  • Your files stay private. Pattern files go only to people who bought them, by a download link that expires after 10 minutes, and every download is logged.
  • Made by people. No AI-generated patterns, and every pattern listing shows a real photo of something sewn from it.

Questions

How much do you keep from a $12 quilt pattern on Etsy?
About $10.41. Etsy's listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee and 3% plus 25 cents processing come to $1.59. If the sale came from an Offsite Ad, the 15% ad fee brings it to $3.39, and you keep $8.61.
Is NiftyFifty cheaper than Payhip for selling patterns?
On fees they come out the same: $1.25 on a $12 pattern on Payhip's free plan and on NiftyFifty. The difference is where the buyers are. NiftyFifty is a marketplace only for quilting, with quilters already browsing it, while a Payhip store relies on you bringing every buyer yourself.
Are there other fees on NiftyFifty?
No listing fees and no monthly subscription. Stripe's payout fees are passed on at cost: $2 in a month you get paid, plus 0.25% and 25 cents per deposit. They are per deposit, not per sale.

Sell your patterns here

A short application, and a real person reads every one.

Apply to sell your patterns