Etsy vs Payhip vs NiftyFifty for quilt patterns: 2026 fees
Fees checked
Here is what happens to a $12 PDF quilt pattern on each site, using each one's published US fees. NiftyFifty and Payhip's free plan come out the same, and both leave you more than Etsy does.
| Where it sells | What's charged | Fees | You keep |
|---|---|---|---|
| Etsy | $0.20 listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee, 3% + $0.25 payment processing | $1.59 | $10.41 |
| Etsy, sale from an Offsite Ad | The same fees, plus a 15% Offsite Ads fee | $3.39 | $8.61 |
| Payhip (free plan) | 5% transaction fee, plus Stripe's card fee of 2.9% + $0.30 | $1.25 | $10.75 |
| NiftyFifty | 5% fee, plus Stripe's card fee of 2.9% + $0.30 at cost | $1.25 | $10.75 |
So what's the difference?
We won't pretend the fees are the whole story: on a $12 pattern we tie with Payhip's free plan. Here's what is different.
- Buyers are already here. A Payhip store is your own storefront, so every buyer has to come from you. NiftyFifty is where quilters already come for blocks, swaps and free tools.
- Only quilting. Your pattern sits next to other quilt patterns, pantographs and classes, not next to everything else for sale on the internet.
- Your files stay private. Pattern files go only to people who bought them, by a download link that expires after 10 minutes, and every download is logged.
- Made by people. No AI-generated patterns, and every pattern listing shows a real photo of something sewn from it.
Questions
- How much do you keep from a $12 quilt pattern on Etsy?
- About $10.41. Etsy's listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee and 3% plus 25 cents processing come to $1.59. If the sale came from an Offsite Ad, the 15% ad fee brings it to $3.39, and you keep $8.61.
- Is NiftyFifty cheaper than Payhip for selling patterns?
- On fees they come out the same: $1.25 on a $12 pattern on Payhip's free plan and on NiftyFifty. The difference is where the buyers are. NiftyFifty is a marketplace only for quilting, with quilters already browsing it, while a Payhip store relies on you bringing every buyer yourself.
- Are there other fees on NiftyFifty?
- No listing fees and no monthly subscription. Stripe's payout fees are passed on at cost: $2 in a month you get paid, plus 0.25% and 25 cents per deposit. They are per deposit, not per sale.
Sell your patterns here
A short application, and a real person reads every one.
Apply to sell your patterns